Path: typhoon.sonic.net!not-for-mail Newsgroups: alt.magick.tyagi,alt.magick,alt.religion.wicca,alt.paranormal.spells.hexes.magic,alt.pagan.magick Subject: Magic, Methods and Ethics (was BOOK REVIEW - Before You Cast a Spell) References: From: nagasiva Reply-To: spam@luckymojo.com User-Agent: nn/6.6.0 Lines: 90 Message-ID: Date: Thu, 22 Jan 2004 22:08:41 GMT NNTP-Posting-Host: 208.201.242.18 X-Complaints-To: abuse@sonic.net X-Trace: typhoon.sonic.net 1074809321 208.201.242.18 (Thu, 22 Jan 2004 14:08:41 PST) NNTP-Posting-Date: Thu, 22 Jan 2004 14:08:41 PST Xref: typhoon.sonic.net alt.magick.tyagi:45648 alt.magick:365288 alt.religion.wicca:805354 alt.paranormal.spells.hexes.magic:37431 alt.pagan.magick:40343 50040122 vii om thanks for the reviews, Mike, they are often valuable. except Llewellyn. "Mike Gleason" [shiftage] re where Carl is going: # On page 9 of this book the first paragraph tells it all: "This book does # not contain any spells, or any specific instructions on how to cast # spells, raise and direct energy, or perform any other kind of magical # procedure." that's important, probably the reason for the "Before" in the title. # Carl's intent is to focus on the spiritual principles of magic.... are there any, beyond doctrines which people apply to it? # There is a tendency for some folks to dismiss this author's works as being # too basic. Perhaps that is because there is a tendency to want instant # gratification and instant success in our society. the popularization and fictionalizing of magic-as-instantaneous gives those who approach the subject of magic some predispositions and prejudices about magic which may be impossible to satisfy. it is for this reason and more that some argue 'magic is all about belief'. # The author believes, as do I, that magic should be the last weapon # in your arsenal. this is in the tradition of those who see magic as a limited resource, stemming from a forbidden or scarce energetic origin, or in some manner problematic, evil, or harmful at base. a conservationist or 'limited arsenal' mentality predominates. I'd say this is largely at variance with most folk magic, which is pragmatically-valuable as a ready-assist at all times by those who persistently employ magic. # First you should try every mundane approach you can. I've heard many Neopagans tell me that they thought this should be an *accompaniment* to magical practice, but few went as far into conservatism as Carl and you do here except within trads that were heavily inhibited or strongly mystically-based. # Too many Pagans do a ritual to achieve their ends and forget to # put any effort into the non-magical approaches. this was the criticism of the above. note that because this is true does not mean that the mundane should be exhausted first. # [Carl] asks [the objectors] to explain why they object to his # position or statement.... because magic isn't so scarce or problematic that it has to be 'the last resort'. it is that kind of thinking that gets the witch or mage fearful of repercussion, lacking in experience, and generally unfamiliar with magic in the slightest. # He stresses the need for each person to take responsibility.... magic hand-wringers sometimes stress this and morality. it is also what ties some political hand-wringers in knots (what if I'm *wrong*? I should never vote or support a candidate at all!). # It is an all too human trait to claim the credit and disavow # the screw-ups. I'm not sure this is true. this type of rudumentary scientism seems to operate with other mammals at least. # ...If you live an ethical life, both in your mundane and your # magical life you may encourage others to do so as well. only if you're interested in putting forth such encouragement. in some locales this is considered akin to proselytizing. # ...he does not oppose payment for teaching.... very big of him. I'm more interested in what he says that backs up the rules he *does* wish to promote (e.g. magic as last resort). if it is just that people don't ground their magical activities in mundane activity, that is insufficient justification for refraining from practicing magic at all unless and until all ordinary methods have proven fruitless. # Before You Cast a Spell by Carl McColman (c) 2004 # New Page Book 143 pages + Appendices & Index paperback, # ISBN 1-56414-716-9 $13.00 (U.S.) thanks again, nagasiva